Wed 16 Aug 2006
I have long believed that there is no such thing as innate talent.
I instead believe that talent is something that is developed over time by practice. I just read an article on Scientific American called the "The Expert Mind." It covers many theories of how the mind works including "chunking" and "templates" which are ways to explain how an expert can store larger amounts of data temporarily by recognizing patterns.
The article also points out that practice alone will not increase ones ability. It points out that the practice must have constant challenges for the growth to occur.
The big quote from the article is: "Teachers in sports, music, and other fields tend to believe that talent matters and that they know it when they see it. In fact, they appear to be confusing ability with precocity."
That is something I can agree with. I have always thought that I can acquire any skill even an artistic one by practice. I can also become talented by enough practice.
When I look at a new skill that I would like to acquire I evaluate it like this. I determine what amount of effort is required to reach different levels, then determine how much of my time I would like to spend to get to what level.
An example is painting. I have often thought that I would like to gain skill in painting but in my mind it would take too long. There are so many tiny skills that go into making someone a good painter that I would have to work for many years to achieve the results I desire. One of the greatest skills of painting is being able to determine what in reality is important. That is when you paint a wall do you paint every brick or just enough bricks to represent the wall.
I know many people really believe in talent even though there is not really any scientific evidence to support it. It may be correct. I think a comment I in the Slashdot discussion about this by Colin Smith sums it all up for the way I think: "Of course The idea that they just worked harder, or rather, better than you is uncomfortable. It means that you're just lazy, don't have the necessary drive or don't know how to train. it's much easier to believe that they are just innately better and it's not really your fault that you can't reach their level. "
Many people tell me that I have computer talent. I agree that I do; but it is only because I have been using computers on average 6 hours a day for over 20 years. I knew nothing at first. I read many books and worked on new and challenging things every day.
September 30th, 2007 at 8:08 am
Well I believe in talent. There are some things that just easier for some than others. People believe in God, even though there is no scientific proof, why not innate abilities?
I have spent almost thirty miserable years trying to find my talent. I honestly believe that I am skilled in nothing.
April 14th, 2008 at 6:52 am
i agree i am not talented at anything because i out for effort for anything cuz i hate to do that so yeah maybe im not building up my talent but that still means right now i have no talents
August 18th, 2008 at 2:40 pm
I believe i have no talent becuase i try at most things and dont achieve amazing things that other talented people can – i am told i am talented but multi talented yet i see people everyday creating things i couldnt even dream about this makes me very sad indeed. i look at people like (sakuri iowata?) nintendo) and i try a hand at making games but i cant code to save my life. is there anyway to find my one true success in life please tell me.
September 12th, 2008 at 4:23 pm
I have no Talent, i can do other things which other people can’t and find things easier, but i can’t do something which really stands out :O -.- maybe i just don’t have it in me?
September 30th, 2008 at 3:35 pm
everyone says I’m good at something. Whether it’s singing, working on a computer, or freakin doing makeup, or writing a book, there is always someone proving they are better than you. Which they are…. Just depends on how much you let them make you feel like crap because you made a silly mistake, like not knowing something didn’t have a power cord….
I don’t deserve this. I have no talent and I quit!!!!
I’m just ready to get it all up. I quit.
November 18th, 2008 at 9:38 am
i have no talent too… everything i do and everything i try it doesnt work out. no matter in studies, sports or whatever… i just suck at everything… just a skiny fucked up 15 year old freak… my only talent is having no talent… god made me and here i am to destroy him…
December 18th, 2008 at 7:26 am
I have no talents either, people often say to me, “your’re good at lots of things.” What the heck are lots of things, seems to me they can’t indeed think of one genuine thing they believe me to be good at. I can’t sing, play any musical instrument, act, dance, play a sport to an above average standard, I’m not terribly academical either. I have tried my hand at plenty of varied activities, I just haven’t found anything I naturally excel at which sucks, I am a waste of space and my life isn’t fair.
January 13th, 2009 at 1:23 pm
I agree with the whole practice-develops-talent concept. If I had cared about developing my talents when I was little, I’d be a good swimmer, artist, writer, and musician. I am none of those things now, nor can I be.
February 4th, 2009 at 10:11 pm
I think God had forgotten to give me a talent. He had forgotten me.
With practice you can become good at something, but not better than those with the talent.
Those talented are blessed, and those without, cursed, for life and meant to suffer. That is all.
March 28th, 2009 at 4:31 am
I spent years practising the piano, and whilst I improved I would not say that I am a good pianist. You can’t get away from it, talent exists. To all those who think they have no talent, I say you are mistakened. Everybody is good at something. May God help you to see that and rejoice. You might be a good cook or a good handiman. Just open your eyes and you will see that you are blessed.
March 31st, 2009 at 8:50 pm
We all have different skill sets. Basic programing that allows us to see things in a different way. Practice your heart out and you will never see the world the way Picasso did, or acquire his talent. One might “master” a new talent, or acquire a new ability, only to find that they have just learned to immitate others.
My greatest skill is an innate sense of imagination. Something many bright people will never have.
One can teach a monkey to operate, but the ability to use that skill in a new way, or when faced with an unusual case, cannot be taught.
Your innate talent lies in how you see the world, how you percieve the how the interlocking elements interact.
Many people drawn to engineering are excellent cooks, and excellent in the sense that they not only can make a nice white sauce (that’s acquired) but can percieve how the dish goes together and just what slight modification would actually taste like before it’s prepared.
So, no you have unique talents, they’re the tools you use to create..
April 6th, 2009 at 6:20 am
it is funny to read all these diffrent views on a subject which has no “real” right or wrong answer, all we can do is take our life, live it to whatever degree we can and for some like my self that is no where,for others they will find thier special nich and of course from that they will presume that we all have a F*#*ing talent. Guess what there is right answer and it’s black and white some people are just here to make other people look good, but at least we all serve a pupose.
April 15th, 2009 at 9:59 pm
I agree with Tara; I think God has forgotten to give me talent. Sure I might be a good cook; keep a clean house and work my butt off for minimum wage. None of that has ever gotten me anywhere. I have been trying to find my talent for the last forty years and will continue until the day I die but I really think I have been cursed and I’m meant to be a low life. I don’t want fame or fortune just to be good at something that I enjoy doing and could make a decent living from. I’ve always been in service to others; told that I’m a good worker but I do not find any joy in anything I do for anyone anymore. When is it going to be my turn?
May 16th, 2009 at 12:54 pm
I believe that God gives us talent. He puts it in our minds and shows us what needs to be done. I believe it is Gods will to give every single person that lives a part in this world. I don’t know why I haven’t found my talent. I’m not smart matter of fact, I couldn’t even graduate from high school. I get no respect, I’m poor, and I’m not even good looking. Sometimes I think that maybe I’m gonna be one of the people that suffers and dies from a disease. Or someone that becomes addicted to some kind of drugs or alchohol. It happens to people, people who have nothing in life. So why wouldn’t it happen to me? Sometimes I feel like I’m destined to fail. Everyone I know sees a bright future for themselves. I try to, I truly want to think and know that I’m going to be okay, but it just doesn’t happen. Maybe God forgot about me, or maybe he just hasn’t gotten to me just yet. I’m very eager to find out.
June 1st, 2009 at 4:45 am
I tried something new today…and failed.
I thought I had no “talent”, then I sat down and looked at something.
I have no “positive” talents. I have many, many, many negative “talents” or traits that have been bestowed upon me. I drink more alcohol on a day to day basis then other people my age. I usually lie and manipulate to get what I want (strangely it works too). I am pretty darn good at ruining people’s days.
Yeah, so all of you out there who say you have no “talent”, just remember, you probably have a whole heap of hidden ones waiting to hurt someone else.
Oh yeah, All the previous posters who say “Maybe God forgot about me”, you are idiots. By stating that God forgot about you, is doubting your Gods potential power, and showing a lack of faith. By showing a lack of faith, you are not giving your life completely to the Lord and thus are not Christian. Burn in hell.
(I am an Atheist)
July 6th, 2009 at 6:15 pm
I have 3 other siblings. and each of them have special skills and talents, while I on the other hand have none. I always feel shit when people kept asking what I am good at, because they all know my family is made up of very talented people, except me..
My Dad always tell me, “because you are not working hard enough! how could you accomplish something?” Hell, I dont believe people actually sacrifice time and effort practicing their so called talent, but because they enjoy what they’re doing, that’s what’s keeping them from giving up, and i still can’t find that kind of passion suitable to me
And it really pisses me off when people tell me “yes you do have a talent. God gave it you. you just need to find it out yourself” This is the reason why I don’t believe in superstitious God bullshit anymore
August 28th, 2009 at 12:19 am
Yeah, I never really what it is I want to do, and get upset when other people show off their talent, they make you feel low about yourself. I know I’m good at somethings in my own way but they are not thing people acknowledge as a talent.
September 2nd, 2009 at 9:42 am
Please do not get down on yourselves. Life is full of possibilities. God has not forgotten about you. He’s waiting for you to find your self so he can step in and point you in the right direction. I guarantee that all these posts about having no talent have been written by young teens. The reason for this is because you haven’t completely found youselves. God is great, he will always be there to guide and support you. If you want happiness he will give it to you. We all have something special and different. Even if you become a grabage truck driver, you will be happy doing it. God knows whats good for you, and he will show you, and place that in your mind. He loves us very much, and if we trust him we will be ok. Never forget, love the Father and anything is possible.
Peace and Love
September 25th, 2009 at 6:24 pm
I have no talent. I’ve tried many things. It’s been music, art, acting, modeling, computers, I have even tried new interests that might bring out talent, and nothing works.
(Those are only a few I have named.)
I don’t believe it grows on you. I was born into a family full of talented people. I’m not smart like my sister, the ability to draw like my mother and brother, my mother is incredibly smart aswell. I’ve never been one to excel in school, or draw a masterpiece.
Even the things I enjoy, I’m not good at. I will never be the kind that people will awe in amazement over. Not that I’m not okay with that, I’d just like to be able to do something well.
I do not believe in god, or any form of a holy character. I do not believe we are given some special talent. It happens, or it doesn’t. Unfortunately, I have been cursed with no talent.
October 7th, 2009 at 6:09 pm
People who have “talent” are people who focus all their time and energy on the things they’re good at. You guys are talented at whining and self obsession. How about we change that into something more productive.
November 11th, 2009 at 3:56 am
I don’t actually know where to start this…
I am good at quite a few things (you could say about average), but I just get by with those things. Like programming, I enjoy it, and make a living from it, but I’m not particularly good at it. I can play sport well. I stand out at a low club level, but anything over that, I’m not good.
I can draw cartoons, but again, only so well
I’m pretty smart, smart enough to cost through school and college without really studying, but I won’t exactly be getting my doctorate for ANYTHING. I enjoy music beyond all else (talent-wise), and I taught myself to play guitar, but I can only kinda play. Any guitar riff that is a little beyond easy, I have no chance.
Hmm, I just came up with something. My mother often tells me I have a very calming nature. That she’ll often come talk to me when she’s having a bad day, because she calms down and realizes that the problem isn’t that bad. On the odd occasion I have found I have the same effect on my brother, but he has never mentioned it.
Could this be my talent?
If so, this is a horrible talent. Why would your god (assuming you believe in a god) give me such a boring talent. I was under the impression that a talent is something you enjoy doing. Something that makes you happy. Even if that means programming a media player for yourself, one that you will never publish or even try make money from.
I have found nothing that gives me the enjoyment and satisfaction we all crave.
Sorry for the long post.
November 11th, 2009 at 4:00 am
Whoops, it’s meant to read, above average, not, ‘about average’.
Coast, not, ‘cost’
I can’t edit it, as it is pending moderation
November 13th, 2009 at 1:09 pm
Well, I’m back. I have not succeed in finding a talent. I have however, found myself in the process. Quite boring, isn’t it?
I could understand how being considered ‘calm’ is a talent. I’m to angry of a person, and often depressed or stressed to be completely calm. It’s not that I don’t try, it’s that is physically impossible for me.
I’ve been drawing every night for the past week. I do it for a few hours at night, comparing it to the object or character I attempted. I usually give up, or bored and watch television.
Maybe I’ll give the piano a shot, next.
Pottery, maybe.
December 9th, 2009 at 5:39 pm
I am fairly good at a lot of things, but not particularly skilled in any one area, there is always someone better than me.
January 8th, 2010 at 1:24 am
I agree with Josh,
but considering my long post above, I have figured something out.
Alright, so I’m good at a few, but not amazingly good at anything. I have come to realize that that is my talent. How many people do you know that are better than the average person at so many things. I can pick and do things easily without formal training.
I can do so many things better than most. Which is awesome, because I can pretty much do anything I want. I’m sporty, smart and creative. I think that’s actually quite a good talent to have.
I wish everyone luck, maybe you’ll find your talent. Maybe it’ll be something you can already do, just haven’t realized it yet
January 10th, 2010 at 2:32 pm
There is no god, and most of us have nothing, absolutely nothing going for us. The chosen few have talent, and we pathetic minions all bow down to them.
February 18th, 2010 at 12:29 am
I am 26yo, and I haven’t decided yet what to study. There is nothing I can do better than the average minion. The only thing I do that the average person can’t do is to realize that there is no god (it only takes common sense to figure that out). But besides having “common” sense, there is nothing that I could make money off. I’d rather be a bum than a mediocre, unemployed engineer who will never see a nobel prize or have any big accomplishments. Oh, having kids is not an accomplishment.
March 1st, 2010 at 8:48 am
I don’t think i have any talent either. I feel like a total loser and always wished i was someone else. I really hope I could be talented one day. I hope God would at least grant me that one day. I believe he could. if he lets me…
but right now i couldn’t help but sulk. everyone around me is good at something. most even smarter than me. i couldn’t achieve my dream being like this. i always wonder why me??
March 18th, 2010 at 11:05 pm
The things that i am good at do not pay the bills.This is not a good filling.I have to stop comparing myself to other people to move forward.There is always hope with out hope what do we have. Peace
March 19th, 2010 at 12:01 pm
I am not going to go into a lengthy paragraph like everyone else, I am just going to agree. I have not talent whatsoever. I tried and tried and I just failed.